<?xml version="1.0" encoding="US-ASCII"?>
<!--XBRL Document Created with Wdesk from Workiva-->
<!--p:E3AD5F0505655496BB49BDEAC3446EB9,x:224081baa3424ab4a39e11fdbfd0a107-->
<xbrli:xbrl xmlns:country="http://xbrl.sec.gov/country/2016-01-31" xmlns:currency="http://xbrl.sec.gov/currency/2016-01-31" xmlns:dei="http://xbrl.sec.gov/dei/2014-01-31" xmlns:exch="http://xbrl.sec.gov/exch/2016-01-31" xmlns:invest="http://xbrl.sec.gov/invest/2013-01-31" xmlns:ipcc="http://www.infinityauto.com/20171231" xmlns:iso4217="http://www.xbrl.org/2003/iso4217" xmlns:link="http://www.xbrl.org/2003/linkbase" xmlns:naics="http://xbrl.sec.gov/naics/2011-01-31" xmlns:nonnum="http://www.xbrl.org/dtr/type/non-numeric" xmlns:num="http://www.xbrl.org/dtr/type/numeric" xmlns:ref="http://www.xbrl.org/2006/ref" xmlns:sic="http://xbrl.sec.gov/sic/2011-01-31" xmlns:stpr="http://xbrl.sec.gov/stpr/2011-01-31" xmlns:us-gaap="http://fasb.org/us-gaap/2016-01-31" xmlns:us-roles="http://fasb.org/us-roles/2016-01-31" xmlns:us-types="http://fasb.org/us-types/2016-01-31" xmlns:utreg="http://www.xbrl.org/2009/utr" xmlns:xbrldi="http://xbrl.org/2006/xbrldi" xmlns:xbrldt="http://xbrl.org/2005/xbrldt" xmlns:xbrli="http://www.xbrl.org/2003/instance" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
	<link:schemaRef xlink:href="ipcc-20171231.xsd" xlink:type="simple" />
	<xbrli:context id="FD2017Q4YTD">
		<xbrli:entity>
			<xbrli:identifier scheme="http://www.sec.gov/CIK">0001195933</xbrli:identifier>
		</xbrli:entity>
		<xbrli:period>
			<xbrli:startDate>2017-01-01</xbrli:startDate>
			<xbrli:endDate>2017-12-31</xbrli:endDate>
		</xbrli:period>
	</xbrli:context>
	<xbrli:context id="I2018Q1Feb09">
		<xbrli:entity>
			<xbrli:identifier scheme="http://www.sec.gov/CIK">0001195933</xbrli:identifier>
		</xbrli:entity>
		<xbrli:period>
			<xbrli:instant>2018-02-09</xbrli:instant>
		</xbrli:period>
	</xbrli:context>
	<xbrli:context id="FI2017Q2">
		<xbrli:entity>
			<xbrli:identifier scheme="http://www.sec.gov/CIK">0001195933</xbrli:identifier>
		</xbrli:entity>
		<xbrli:period>
			<xbrli:instant>2017-06-30</xbrli:instant>
		</xbrli:period>
	</xbrli:context>
	<xbrli:unit id="usd">
		<xbrli:measure>iso4217:USD</xbrli:measure>
	</xbrli:unit>
	<xbrli:unit id="shares">
		<xbrli:measure>xbrli:shares</xbrli:measure>
	</xbrli:unit>
	<dei:AmendmentFlag contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-524A846C0BEE5BF7A3A611577A0DDFFD">false</dei:AmendmentFlag>
	<dei:CurrentFiscalYearEndDate contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-D003D912C50452EC98D630FB4E8D0D2D">--12-31</dei:CurrentFiscalYearEndDate>
	<dei:DocumentFiscalPeriodFocus contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-D866E20826E257D4ABE62322E320AF44">FY</dei:DocumentFiscalPeriodFocus>
	<dei:DocumentFiscalYearFocus contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-4B1C8DA6E125565686F174ADBDE019D0">2017</dei:DocumentFiscalYearFocus>
	<dei:DocumentPeriodEndDate contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-38CEA4949FC05EEE982A1FDCB0C1D841">2017-12-31</dei:DocumentPeriodEndDate>
	<dei:DocumentType contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-6B3D84FBCD66547FA7F1B0D4600547E4">10-K/A</dei:DocumentType>
	<dei:EntityCentralIndexKey contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-205DFAA029A553A893FE885CA5066073">0001195933</dei:EntityCentralIndexKey>
	<dei:EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding contextRef="I2018Q1Feb09" decimals="0" id="Fact-BF414C3F85385778A2AFE2235DDACB9B" unitRef="shares">10941936</dei:EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding>
	<dei:EntityCurrentReportingStatus contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-1359AD3720A05BCA98984FFD55233419">Yes</dei:EntityCurrentReportingStatus>
	<dei:EntityFilerCategory contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-394BD44416DB5687981430F85C4048C3">Large Accelerated Filer</dei:EntityFilerCategory>
	<dei:EntityPublicFloat contextRef="FI2017Q2" decimals="0" id="Fact-216B7DF8EBB255C1ABEEBA8C29203EC3" unitRef="usd">1007156859</dei:EntityPublicFloat>
	<dei:EntityRegistrantName contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-1427B8EE27A9566FB632694C05E69778">INFINITY PROPERTY &amp; CASUALTY CORP</dei:EntityRegistrantName>
	<dei:EntityVoluntaryFilers contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-DD56AE0AAD02561F97026E7F67E1B830">No</dei:EntityVoluntaryFilers>
	<dei:EntityWellKnownSeasonedIssuer contextRef="FD2017Q4YTD" id="Fact-1AACEF16CA35584E8DEE3812B62B8C3E">Yes</dei:EntityWellKnownSeasonedIssuer>
	<link:footnoteLink xlink:role="http://www.xbrl.org/2003/role/link" xlink:type="extended">
	</link:footnoteLink>
</xbrli:xbrl>