Please wait

Exhibit (c)(10)

Trading & Transaction Comparables Project Trans Am June 2018

 

Selected Precedent Simplification Transactions Total Transaction Value ($mm) Consideration Mix (Cash / Stock) Announce Date Premiums Paid Acquiror Target 1-Day 30-Day 60-Day VTTI BV High 44.4% 60.0% 97.4% Source: Company filings, Factset. Note: Summary statistics exclude Hamm / Hiland. 1. Cheniere Energy, Inc. premiums as of undisturbed price (5/16/2018 less $0.56 dividend; CQH traded ex-dividend on 5/18/2018). Original offer of 0.4500x represented $28.24 per share. Final offer was a 9.5% premium to original offer price. 2. Transaction value represents 100% of enterprise value of pro forma consolidated entity. 1 Mean11.0%13.4%13.1% Median 8.7%10.4% 9.9% Low(8.6%)(6.0%)(23.5%) 6/19/2018 Holdings (1) $1,243(0% / 100%)12.9%11.3%11.6% 5/17/2018 $2,174(0% / 100%)0.0%0.9%(22.0%) 5/17/2018 $2,728(0% / 100%)0.0%(0.9%)(16.6%) 5/17/2018 $749(0% / 100%)0.0%0.8%(21.9%) 5/17/2018 $3,216(0% / 100%)5.2%5.2%5.0% 5/17/2018 $10,500(0% / 100%)6.4%19.5%5.8% 3/26/2018 $4,000(0% / 100%)0.6%(6.0%)(23.5%) 2/8/2018 $780(0% / 100%)1.7%12.0%3.2% 1/2/2018 $1,381(0% / 100%)23.4%24.8%2.7% 11/8/2017 $160(0% / 100%)2.0%19.2%36.5% 8/29/2017 $657(100% / 0%)15.2%7.5%16.2% 8/14/2017 $1,754(0% / 100%)6.4%(1.4%)2.4% 6/2/2017 $157(0% / 100%)5.8%(1.1%)4.6% 5/18/2017 $331(0% / 100%)20.1%16.3%27.0% 3/2/2017 $790(100% / 0%)1.9%10.0%8.8% 2/1/2017 (2) $17,229(0% / 100%)25.4%22.6%37.8% 1/27/2017 $170(0% / 100%)(8.6%)10.3%3.2% 11/21/2016 $44,676(0% / 100%)(0.2%)6.8%(1.6%) 9/26/2016 $1,848(100% / 0%)6.3%14.0%23.3% 8/1/2016 $351(0% / 100%)21.0%5.2%9.9% 5/31/2016 $734(0% / 100%)0.0%60.0%97.4% 12/21/2015 $1,825(53% / 47%)17.8%12.2%14.4% 11/3/2015 $11,327(0% / 100%)18.4%8.6%9.8% 5/13/2015 $21,054(0% / 100%)17.8%13.5%17.2% 5/6/2015 $5,052(0% / 100%)17.2%27.6%28.6% 4/6/2015 $484(0% / 100%)8.6%4.7%9.5% 1/26/2015 $17,963(1% / 99%)13.2%10.7%(14.1%) 8/10/2014 $50,209(12% / 88%)12.0%10.5%20.0% $10,635(0% / 100%)16.5%14.8%25.6% $10,162(12% / 88%)15.4%7.3%17.3% 6/15/2014 $36,655(0% / 100%)6.5%8.1%12.7% 8/27/2013 $938(0% / 100%)8.7%1.6%9.8% 2/23/2011 $3,305(0% / 100%)36.1%40.1%42.9% 7/29/2009 $61(100% / 0%)44.4%54.8%18.1% OSG America L.P. 6/29/2009 $5,894(0% / 100%)9.3%14.9%34.2% 1/15/2009Harold Hamm $67(100% / 0%)6.7% / 33.3%(7.0%) / 35.6%16.3% / 40.4% Premiums Paid

 

TransMontaigne Partners LP Comparables Trans-Buckeye Global Martin Magellan PBF Sprague USD Note: Median excludes TLP statistics. 1. Calculated using 25.0x equity value multiple on 2018E GP cash flows. TLP’s GP equity value assumed to be $400mm for illustrat ive purposes. 2 ($ in millions, except per unit data) Ticker Current Unit Price as of 6/19/18 % of 52-Week High LP Units Outstanding Median Montaigne Partners Partners LP Midstream Midstream Logistics Resources LP Partners LP TLP $37.98 80% 16.2 BPL GLP MMLP MMP PBFX SRLP USDP $36.39 $17.10 $13.85 $69.54 $21.20 $23.60 $11.05 55% 91% 70% 92% 95% 78% 92% 146.9 34.0 39.1 228.2 42.0 22.7 26.1 84% 10.6x 9.9x 9.0x 10.94% 12.53% 12.76% 12.37% 2.3% 2.5% 13.5% 1.3% 1.3% 1.04x 73.2% 3.5x 3.5x LP Equity Value $616.1 GP Equity Value (1) 400.0 $5,347.0 $581.3 $540.9 $15,868.7 $890.0 $536.4 $288.8 - 10.5 39.8 - 333.7 225.4 27.0 Total Equity Value $1,016.1 Non-Controlling Interest - Preferred Equity - MLP Total Debt 582.4 MLP Cash (0.9) Unconsolidated HoldCo Net Debt - $5,347.0 $591.9 $580.7 $15,868.7 $1,223.7 $761.8 $315.9 279.4 3.0 - - 170.9 - - - - - - - - - 4,703.1 1,210.1 795.1 4,523.3 597.2 692.1 201.8 (6.6) (11.7) (0.2) (74.2) (17.0) (5.6) (6.4) - - - - - - - Total Enterprise Value $1,597.6 Enterprise Value / 2018E EBITDA 11.6x 2019E EBITDA 10.5x 2020E EBITDA 9.8x MLP Statistics LQA Yield 8.27% 2018E DCF Yield 10.23% 2019E DCF Yield 10.90% 2020E DCF Yield 11.85% 2018 - 2020 Expected Distribution CAGR 7.2% 2018 - 2021 Expected Distribution CAGR 6.9% Implied Total Return 15.2% Current Split 50.0% % of Total Cash Distributed to GP 23.3% 2018E DCF per LP / LQA Coverage 1.24x Credit Statistics Total Debt / Total Book Capitalization 61.7% Total Debt / 2018E EBITDA 4.2x Net Debt / 2018E EBITDA 4.2x $10,323.0 $1,793.3 $1,375.6 $20,317.8 $1,974.8 $1,448.2 $511.4 9.6x 6.8x 8.8x 14.7x 12.6x 11.6x 9.0x 8.7x 8.2x 8.4x 13.8x 11.3x 11.2x 9.7x 8.1x 8.1x 8.2x 12.6x 9.8x 11.2x 9.9x 13.88% 10.82% 14.44% 5.39% 9.25% 11.06% 12.76% 12.78% 18.84% 14.07% 6.82% 8.85% 12.28% 14.98% 13.24% 13.29% 16.80% 7.11% 8.97% 12.28% 12.59% 13.91% 13.13% 17.71% 7.94% 9.92% 11.61% 12.32% - - 0.7% 6.0% 3.9% 6.5% - - - 1.2% 5.7% 3.9% 6.5% - 13.9% 10.8% 15.6% 11.1% 13.1% 17.6% 12.8% - 0.7% 2.0% - 50.0% 50.0% 15.0% - 0.7% 2.0% - 12.5% 10.4% 2.9% 0.92x 1.74x 0.97x 1.27x 0.96x 1.11x 1.17x 48.0% 73.4% 73.2% 67.9% 73.3% 78.5% 71.7% 4.4x 3.3x 5.1x 3.3x 3.8x 3.0x 3.5x 4.4x 3.2x 5.1x 3.2x 3.7x 3.0x 3.4x Trading Comparables

 

Disclaimer This document has been prepar ed by Barcl ays C apit al I nc. (“B arclays”) for i nfor mati on purpos es onl y. This document is c onfi dential and for t he sol e and exclusi ve benefit and int ernal us e of ArcLight Capital Part ners, LLC (the “Reci pient”) in co nn ectio n wit h t he matt er or possi ble tr ans actio n to which t his doc u me nt rel ates , a nd no p art of it ma y be re pro duc ed, distrib ut ed or tra ns mitte d wit ho ut t he prior writte n per missio n of B arcla ys. This doc u me nt is an in dicati ve su mmar y of the terms and c onditions of the trans action described herei n and may be amended, s uperseded or replac ed by s ubs equent s ummaries. T he final terms and c onditions of t he tr ans action will be set out in full in the applic abl e bi ndi ng transaction document(s). This document is incomplete without reference to, and should be assessed solely in conjunction with, the oral briefing provided by Barclays. Neith er Barcla ys n or an y of its s ubsi diaries or affilia tes s hall be oblig e d by ha vi ng ma de this doc ume nt a vaila ble to yo u to pro vi de an y fin anci al ad vis or y ser vice s (whet her in r elati on to t he ma tter or possi ble tr ans actio n to which this doc umen t rel ate s or ot h erwis e) or to sell, acq uir e, plac e or un der write any s ecuriti es or to l en d mo ne ys or to pro vid e an y oth er c ommit me nt, fa cility, prod uct, ris k ma nag e ment s oluti on or s er vice, n or do es Barcla ys re pres ent by pro vidi ng this doc ument to t he Reci pient t hat it will be possibl e f or B arclays to provide, arrange or undert ake any of the aforementi oned ser vices, acti vities , pr oducts or sol utions. A ny c ommit ment by B arclays to provi de, arrange or undertake any of the af ore me ntio ne d s er vices, ac tivi ties, pro duc ts or sol utio ns would be s ubj ect to Barcl a ys sig ning ap pro priate d ocu ment ati on, o btai ning all n ecess ar y in tern al ap pro vals a nd co mpleti ng d ue dilig enc e, in eac h c ase in a man ner s atisf actor y to Barclays. This doc ument was pr epared on t he basis of i nfor mation and dat a, obt ained from publicl y available sources and, where applicable, from t he Reci pient and/ or any other entit y t hat may be invol ved in any trans acti on or matter c ontempl at ed by t his document (and/ or any of t he R ecipi ent’s or t he af orementi oned entities’ affiliates), in eac h case prior to or on the dat e hereof. B arclays makes no warrant y or repres entati on, express or i mplied, as to t he acc urac y or c omplet eness of informati on whic h is contai ned in this doc ument and whic h is stat ed to have been obt ained from or is based upon trade and st atistical s ervic es or ot her third party s ourc es. The inf ormation in this doc ument has not been independentl y verified by B arclays and B arclays does not assume any li abilit y for any suc h infor mati on. A ny dat a on past perf ormanc e, modeling or bac k-t esti ng contai ned herei n is no indicati on as to fut ure performanc e. No r epres entati on is made as to the reas onabl eness of the assumptions made withi n or the ac curac y or c ompleteness of any modeli ng or bac k-t esting or any other informati on c ontai ned herei n. All opini ons and esti mates are given as of the dat e hereof and are s ubj ect to cha ng e an d Barcl a ys assu mes no o blig atio n to u pd at e t his d ocu me nt to refl ect any s uch c ha ng es. Th e valu e of any i n vest ment ma y fl uctu at e as a r esult of mar ket c ha ng es. Th e inf ormatio n her ein is not int e nd ed to pr edict a ctu al res ults and no assurances are g iven with respect thereto. Nothing herein shall be deemed to constitute investment , leg al, tax, financial, accounting or other advice. The Reci pient is responsi ble f or maki ng its own independent investigation and appraisal of the risks, benefi ts, appropriat eness and s uitabilit y of any transac tion or matter c ont emplated by t his doc ument and Barclays is not maki ng any recommendation (personal or ot her wise) or givi ng any i nvest ment advice and will have no liability with respect theret o. T he decision to proceed with any trans action or acti on cont emplat ed by this document must be made by the R ecipient in the light of its own commercial assessments and Barclays will not be responsible for such assessments. Neith er Barcla ys nor any of its sub sidiaries or affilia tes, nor any of th eir respec ti ve directors, offic ers, e mplo ye es, a d visors or o th er repres ent ati ves (Barcla ys tog et her with s uc h pers ons bei ng the “B arcla ys Gro up”) acc ep ts an y li abilit y wh ats oe ver f or an y direct , i ndirect or co nseq u e ntial loss es (in co ntrac t, t ort or oth erwis e) arising fro m th e use of t his doc u me nt or its co nt ents or any reli anc e on t he inf ormatio n co ntai ne d her ein. B arcla ys Grou p is not res po nsibl e f or an y specialized advice (including financial, tax, legal and accounting, among other advice). This doc umen t do es no t c onsti tut e nor d oes it form part of an off er to s ell or p urch ase, or th e solicita tio n of an offer to sell or p urchas e, any s ecuriti es or any of t he b usin esses or ass ets d escribe d h erein or an offer or r eco mme nd atio n to enter into any transaction described herein nor does this document constitute an offer or commitment to provide, arrang e or underwrite any financing . Members of the Barclays Group ar e invol ved in a wi de range of c ommercial banking, i nves tment banking and other acti vities out of whic h c onflicti ng int erests or duties may arise. In t he or dinar y course of its busi nes s, t he B arclays Group may provide ser vices to any ot her entit y or pers on whet her or not a member of t he s ame group as the Reci pient (a “Third P art y”), engage in any tr ans action (whether on its own acc ount, on behalf of any Third P art y or ot her wis e, and includi ng any tr ans action or matt er c ont empl ated by t his doc ument), not wit hst anding t hat suc h s er vices, transac tions or acti ons may be advers e to t he Reci pient or any member of the R ecipi ent’s group, and t he B arclays Gr oup may ret ain for its own benefit any r elat ed remunerati on or profit. The B arclays Group operat es in acc ordanc e wit h a conflicts of i nt erest polic y which identifi es c onflicts of int erest it f aces in the ordinary course of its business, and est ablis hes org anisati on al an d pr oce dural meas ures to man ag e t hos e c on flicts wh ere it is re aso na bl y abl e to do s o. N eith er B arcla ys nor an y ot her part of th e Barcla ys Gro up sh all h a ve any d ut y to disclo se to th e Reci pie nt or utilis e f or th e R ecipie nt’s be nefit an y no n-p ublic inf ormatio n acq uir ed in t h e co urse of pro vidi ng ser vices to any ot her p erso n, e ng ag ing in any tran sacti on (o n its o wn acc ou nt or oth erwis e) or ot her wise c arryi ng on its busi ness. T he Barcla ys Gr ou p’s rese arch an al ysts a nd res earch de part me nts ar e ind ep en de nt fro m its ba n king b usin ess a nd ar e subj ect to certai n reg ulati ons a nd i ntern al p olicies. Th e B arcla ys Gro up’s rese arch an al ysts ma y h old o pini ons a nd ma ke st ate ments or invest me nt recommendations and/or publish res earch reports wit h r espect to any c ompany ref erred to herein, t he transacti ons cont emplated herei n or any person or entit y i nvol ved therei n or related t hereto that diff er from or are i nconsist ent with t he views or advic e c ommunic ated by t he B arclays Gr oup’s banki ng business. Barcl ays is a f ull ser vic e sec urities firm and as s uch from ti me to time may ef fect transacti ons for its own account or t he acc ount of i ts clients and hol d long or s hort positions in debt, equity or other securities of the companies referred to herein. THIS DOCUMENT DO ES NOT DISC LOS E A LL THE RI SK S AND OTHER S IGNIFIC ANT IS SUE S RE LAT ED TO AN INV ESTMENT IN THE SECURITI ES, FINANCI AL INSTRUMENTS OR TRAN SACTI ONS DE SCRIB ED HER EIN. PRIOR TO TRANSACTING, YOU SHOULD ENSURE THAT YOU FULLY UNDERSTAND THE TERMS OF THE TRANSACTION AND ANY APPLICABLE RISKS. The inf ormation c ontai ned herei n is not int ended to be distributed to any pros pec tive or act ual investors and, accordi ngly, may not be s hown or gi ven to any person ot her than t he recipi ent, and is not to be for war ded to any ot her pers on (including any ret ail i n vest or or cus to mer), co pie d or ot her wis e re prod uc ed or distrib ute d to any s uch p erso n in an y man ner wh atso e ver. FA ILURE TO COMP LY WITH THIS DIRECT IVE CAN RE SULT IN A VIO LATI ON OF THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED. Thes e materi als have not been produced by t he B arclays Gr oup’s research department and do not constit ut e inves tment research or a res earc h recommendati on f or the purpos es of t he Financial Conduct A ut horit y rules or a research report under applicable U.S. law. Barclays Capital I nc. is t he U nited St ates invest ment bank of B arclays Bank P LC. B arclays Bank P LC is aut horised by the Prudential Reg ulati on A uthorit y and regulated by the Fi nancial Conduct A ut horit y and the Prudenti al R egulati on Authority (Financial Services Register No. 122702). Registered in England. Registered No. 1026167. Registered office: 1 Churchill Place, London E14 5HP. Copyright Barclays Bank PLC, 2018 (all rights reserved). 3